#26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post Reply
Lilliana Howell
Posts: 206
Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

#26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Lilliana Howell »

Image
Image
Defendant Name: Lilliana Hirano
Defendant Phone: N/A
(( Defendant Discord: .kempi ))
(( Defendant Timezone: UTC+1 ))
Type of Representation (Pick one): Public Defender
Image
Charging Department: LSPD
Image
Date & Time of Incident(s): 21/APR/2026 03:10 PM
Charge(s):
  • VF01 - Evading an Officer
  • GF03 - Armed Robbery
  • GF03 - Armed Robbery
Narrative:
I wish to appeal the charges as they were placed on me without any information given.



I, Firstname Lastname, hereby affirm that all information provided above is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, and understand that knowingly providing false information could result in additional charges and/or fines. (( I affirm that all information submitted has been obtained via In-Character means. ))
Image
User avatar
Joseph Horton
Judicial Branch
Posts: 1250
Joined: 28 Apr 2025, 11:25
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

Re: State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Joseph Horton »

Image


San Andreas Judicial Branch
Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"


NOTICE OF RECEIPT

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

The State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

The court has hereby received and acknowledged the above case on the 25th day of April, 2026.


The Superior Court Bench Trial system runs off of defendant responsiveness. If defendants are interacting with the court or their attorney, a Notice to Schedule will be posted with all parties being able note their availability. A Judge will then pick the most suitable time for trial. Once a trial has been scheduled, the court will consider most submissions to be final.

Prior to scheduling, the defendant is encouraged to reach out to a licensed defense attorney in order to prepare a proper defense. The defendant is further encouraged to speak with an authorized individual at Rockford Hills City Hall, Mission Row Police Station, or Paleto Bay Sheriff's Office for official clarification on the specific charges received and their respective date and times, as once the case has been activated, any omitted charges will be considered abandoned and unable to be disputed within this case.

Respectfully,

Image
Associate Justice
San Andreas Judicial Branch
274-6959 - [email protected]
Image
User avatar
Joseph Horton
Judicial Branch
Posts: 1250
Joined: 28 Apr 2025, 11:25
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

Re: State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Joseph Horton »

Image


San Andreas Judicial Branch
Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"


NOTICE OF ACTIVATION & ORDER FOR DISCOVERY

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

The State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A Notice of Activation & Order for Discovery was entered in the above case on the 25th day of April, 2026.


The case of State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano is hereby activated and opened by this Court.

The Superior Court Bench Trial system runs off of defendant responsiveness. If defendants are interacting with the court or their attorney, a Notice to Schedule will be posted with all parties being able note their availability. A Judge will then pick the most suitable time for trial. Once a trial has been scheduled, the court will consider most submissions to be final.

The prosecution and defense are hereby ordered to provide their evidence to the Court via Motion for Discovery within the next 30 days or file a Motion for Continuance.

If at any point in time the defense or prosecution wishes set precedence or desire a formal criminal trial, they are welcome to file a Motion for a Change in Venue

Respectfully,

Image
Associate Justice
San Andreas Judicial Branch
274-6959 - [email protected]
Image
User avatar
Rowin Lawson
Judicial Branch
Posts: 803
Joined: 14 Jan 2024, 19:03
ECRP Forum Name: akcoffeeman
Discord:

SAJB Awards

Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Rowin Lawson »

Image



San Andreas Judicial Branch

Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

MOTION FOR DISCOVERY

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A Motion for Discovery was filed in the above case on the 25th day of May, 2026.


The State of San Andreas, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion for Discovery, and presents the following as evidence;

  • Exhibit #1 Arrest Report
    Image
    lspdlogo

    Los Santos Police Department

    WARRANT REPORT
    "TO PROTECT AND TO SERVE"


    • SUSPECT DETAILS
      • Full Name: Lilliana Howell
        Phone Number: 4857557
        Officers Involved:
        • Police Detective II Mick Wegman
        Charges:
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • VF01 - Evading an Officer
      INCIDENT NARRATIVE
      • Explain what happened, sufficient detail must be given to validate the justify the placed charges, videos could be provided.
        • On 11/APR/2026 Detective Wegman from the Los Santos Police Department managed to locate an active store robbery and move in arresting Joe Ryan and Lilliana Howell.

          On 12/APR/2026 a Store Robbery was called out over the BOLO Database, it can be seen both suspects match identical with the same clothing and tattoos on the CCTV of RanchoRetail at 18:51 12/APR/2026, 20 Hours after being arrested from the arrest on 11/MAR/2026.

          Later in the day we located both Lilliana Howell and Joe Ryan at Legion square and attempted to pull them over which they refused and led to a short chase where they evaded, shown by case 223944 the driver can match the same physical features as Lilliana Howell & Driver of BF400 matches to Joe Ryan from roughly 20 hours ago.

          On 28/MAR/2026 Detective Knight located Lilliana Howell and managed to identify Lilliana Howell on a BOLO during an arrest wearing the same outfits. Lilliana matched 2 Bolos' from 20:16 28/MAR/2026 & 20:23 28/MAR/2026.

          Lilliana matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 & 28/MAR/2026 of active robberies grabbing cash from a store. Lilliana Howell also matched the description of a driver of a vehicle that took off evading from officers.

          Joe Ryan matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 aiming a gun during an active robbery allowing Lilliana Howell grab cash then evade. Joe Ryan also matched the driver of the BF400 that evaded from officers after locating them at Legion Square after robbing stores.

          Related to case 223944 MCD
        Method of Identification
        • VISUAL IDENTIFICATION
      EVIDENCE DETAILS
      • Document the possessions confiscated from the arrested suspect.
        Illegal evidence must be documented individually, examples of documented illegal evidence are "Pistol .50" or "12 grams of Cocaine". Body camera footage/pictures may be attached as an evidence exhibit.

        Where possible the serial number of each firearm seized as evidence should be noted.
        • Illegal Evidence:

          Photograph of possessions in evidence locker (if applicable)
          Image
    Image
Rowin Lawson
Attorney General
San Andreas Judicial Branch
451-9939 - [email protected]
Image
Lilliana Howell
Posts: 206
Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Lilliana Howell »

Image



San Andreas Judicial Branch

Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

MOTION TO SUPPRESS


IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A Motion to Suppress was filed in the above case on the 25th of May, 2026


The Defendant, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion to Suppress, and requests to following be suppressed from evidence;


  • Exhibit #: Highlighted areas, Arrest Report
    Requested Evidence to Suppress:
    Exhibit #1 Arrest Report
    Image
    lspdlogo

    Los Santos Police Department

    WARRANT REPORT
    "TO PROTECT AND TO SERVE"


    • SUSPECT DETAILS
      • Full Name: Lilliana Howell
        Phone Number: 4857557
        Officers Involved:
        • Police Detective II Mick Wegman
        Charges:
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • VF01 - Evading an Officer
      INCIDENT NARRATIVE
      • Explain what happened, sufficient detail must be given to validate the justify the placed charges, videos could be provided.
        • On 11/APR/2026 Detective Wegman from the Los Santos Police Department managed to locate an active store robbery and move in arresting Joe Ryan and Lilliana Howell.

          On 12/APR/2026 a Store Robbery was called out over the BOLO Database, it can be seen both suspects match identical with the same clothing and tattoos on the CCTV of RanchoRetail at 18:51 12/APR/2026,
          20 Hours after being arrested from the arrest on 11/MAR/2026.

          Later in the day we located both Lilliana Howell and Joe Ryan at Legion square and attempted to pull them over which they refused and led to a short chase where they evaded, shown by case 223944 the driver can match the same physical features as Lilliana Howell & Driver of BF400 matches to Joe Ryan from roughly 20 hours ago.

          On 28/MAR/2026 Detective Knight located Lilliana Howell and managed to identify Lilliana Howell on a BOLO during an arrest wearing the same outfits. Lilliana matched 2 Bolos' from 20:16 28/MAR/2026 & 20:23 28/MAR/2026.

          Lilliana matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 & 28/MAR/2026 of active robberies grabbing cash from a store. Lilliana Howell also matched the description of a driver of a vehicle that took off evading from officers.

          Joe Ryan matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 aiming a gun during an active robbery allowing Lilliana Howell grab cash then evade. Joe Ryan also matched the driver of the BF400 that evaded from officers after locating them at Legion Square after robbing stores.

          Related to case 223944 MCD
        Method of Identification
        • VISUAL IDENTIFICATION
      EVIDENCE DETAILS
      • Document the possessions confiscated from the arrested suspect.
        Illegal evidence must be documented individually, examples of documented illegal evidence are "Pistol .50" or "12 grams of Cocaine". Body camera footage/pictures may be attached as an evidence exhibit.

        Where possible the serial number of each firearm seized as evidence should be noted.
        • Illegal Evidence:

          Photograph of possessions in evidence locker (if applicable)
          Image
    • Detailed Reasoning: The highlighted statements are demonstrably false, the defendant was not arrested on the 11th nor 12th of April as evidenced by their criminal record.
  • Exhibit #: Highlighted areas, Arrest Report
    Requested Evidence to Suppress:
    Exhibit #1 Arrest Report
    Image
    lspdlogo

    Los Santos Police Department

    WARRANT REPORT
    "TO PROTECT AND TO SERVE"

    • SUSPECT DETAILS
      • Full Name: Lilliana Howell
        Phone Number: 4857557
        Officers Involved:
        • Police Detective II Mick Wegman
        Charges:
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • VF01 - Evading an Officer
      INCIDENT NARRATIVE
      • Explain what happened, sufficient detail must be given to validate the justify the placed charges, videos could be provided.
        • On 11/APR/2026 Detective Wegman from the Los Santos Police Department managed to locate an active store robbery and move in arresting Joe Ryan and Lilliana Howell.

          On 12/APR/2026 a Store Robbery was called out over the BOLO Database, it can be seen both suspects match identical with the same clothing and tattoos on the CCTV of RanchoRetail at 18:51 12/APR/2026, 20 Hours after being arrested from the arrest on 11/MAR/2026.

          Later in the day we located both Lilliana Howell and Joe Ryan at Legion square and attempted to pull them over which they refused and led to a short chase where they evaded, shown by case 223944 the driver can match the same physical features as Lilliana Howell & Driver of BF400 matches to Joe Ryan from roughly 20 hours ago.

          On 28/MAR/2026 Detective Knight located Lilliana Howell and managed to identify Lilliana Howell on a BOLO during an arrest wearing the same outfits. Lilliana matched 2 Bolos' from 20:16 28/MAR/2026 & 20:23 28/MAR/2026.

          Lilliana matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 & 28/MAR/2026 of active robberies grabbing cash from a store. Lilliana Howell also matched the description of a driver of a vehicle that took off evading from officers.

          Joe Ryan matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 aiming a gun during an active robbery allowing Lilliana Howell grab cash then evade. Joe Ryan also matched the driver of the BF400 that evaded from officers after locating them at Legion Square after robbing stores.

          Related to case 223944 MCD
        Method of Identification
        • VISUAL IDENTIFICATION
      EVIDENCE DETAILS
      • Document the possessions confiscated from the arrested suspect.
        Illegal evidence must be documented individually, examples of documented illegal evidence are "Pistol .50" or "12 grams of Cocaine". Body camera footage/pictures may be attached as an evidence exhibit.

        Where possible the serial number of each firearm seized as evidence should be noted.
        • Illegal Evidence:

          Photograph of possessions in evidence locker (if applicable)
          Image
    • Detailed Reasoning: The highlighted segments reference something that another officer witnessed but is writing if off as fact, as such it should be suppressed as hearsay.
  • Exhibit #: Highlighted areas, Arrest Report
    Requested Evidence to Suppress:
    Exhibit #1 Arrest Report
    Image
    lspdlogo

    Los Santos Police Department

    WARRANT REPORT
    "TO PROTECT AND TO SERVE"

    • SUSPECT DETAILS
      • Full Name: Lilliana Howell
        Phone Number: 4857557
        Officers Involved:
        • Police Detective II Mick Wegman
        Charges:
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • GF03 - Armed Robbery
        • VF01 - Evading an Officer
      INCIDENT NARRATIVE
      • Explain what happened, sufficient detail must be given to validate the justify the placed charges, videos could be provided.
        • On 11/APR/2026 Detective Wegman from the Los Santos Police Department managed to locate an active store robbery and move in arresting Joe Ryan and Lilliana Howell.

          On 12/APR/2026 a Store Robbery was called out over the BOLO Database, it can be seen both suspects match identical with the same clothing and tattoos on the CCTV of RanchoRetail at 18:51 12/APR/2026, 20 Hours after being arrested from the arrest on 11/MAR/2026.

          Later in the day we located both Lilliana Howell and Joe Ryan at Legion square and attempted to pull them over which they refused and led to a short chase where they evaded, shown by case 223944 the driver can match the same physical features as Lilliana Howell & Driver of BF400 matches to Joe Ryan from roughly 20 hours ago.

          On 28/MAR/2026 Detective Knight located Lilliana Howell and managed to identify Lilliana Howell on a BOLO during an arrest wearing the same outfits. Lilliana matched 2 Bolos' from 20:16 28/MAR/2026 & 20:23 28/MAR/2026.

          Lilliana matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 & 28/MAR/2026 of active robberies grabbing cash from a store. Lilliana Howell also matched the description of a driver of a vehicle that took off evading from officers.

          Joe Ryan matched pictures taken on 12/MAR/2026 aiming a gun during an active robbery allowing Lilliana Howell grab cash then evade. Joe Ryan also matched the driver of the BF400 that evaded from officers after locating them at Legion Square after robbing stores.

          Related to case 223944 MCD
        Method of Identification
        • VISUAL IDENTIFICATION
      EVIDENCE DETAILS
      • Document the possessions confiscated from the arrested suspect.
        Illegal evidence must be documented individually, examples of documented illegal evidence are "Pistol .50" or "12 grams of Cocaine". Body camera footage/pictures may be attached as an evidence exhibit.

        Where possible the serial number of each firearm seized as evidence should be noted.
        • Illegal Evidence:

          Photograph of possessions in evidence locker (if applicable)
          Image
    • Detailed Reasoning: The highlighted segments lack relevance to the defendants arrest
Lilliana Hirano
Self Representing
Image
Last edited by Lilliana Howell on 25 May 2026, 06:17, edited 1 time in total.
Lilliana Howell
Posts: 206
Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Lilliana Howell »

Image



San Andreas Judicial Branch

Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY


IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A Motion to Compel Discovery was filed in the above case on the 25th of May, 2026


The Defendant, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion to Compel Discovery, and requests as follows;


  • Requested Discovery: MCD Case 223944
    • Detailed Reasoning: MCD case 223944 is referenced several times within in the arrest report as the ground for the defendants arrest and as such should be added in full to discovery for the defendant to properly be able to defend themselves.

  • Requested Discovery: BOLOS referenced in Arrest Report
    • Detailed Reasoning: There are several BOLO images referenced throughout the arrest report which solidified the grounds for the visual identification, these images should be attached to the arrest report for the defendant to be able to properly defend themselves.




Lilliana Hirano
Self-Representing
User avatar
Hope Kant
Judicial Branch
Posts: 6481
Joined: 30 Jan 2021, 19:56
ECRP Forum Name:
Discord:

SAJB Awards

Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Hope Kant »

Image


San Andreas Judicial Branch
Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"


COURT DECISION

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

The State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A decision was reached in the above case on the 5th day of June, 2026.


The Court apologies for the delay in their response. That being said, we have reviewed the Motion to Suppress followed by the Motion to Compel. The Court find the Motion to Compel to be a standard request based off of information referenced in the arrest report. If the prosecution can provide said information, that will greatly change the Courts position on whether certain information should be allow to remain or be removed from the docket.

The Court is giving the Prosecution seven (7) days to comply with the Motion to Compel or submit a Motion for Continuance with a valid reason for additional time. If this is not adhered to, the Court will be forced to make a ruling on the discovery as presented.

So Ordered,

Image
Chief Justice
San Andreas Judicial Branch
505-9925 - [email protected]
Image
Image
User avatar
Rowin Lawson
Judicial Branch
Posts: 803
Joined: 14 Jan 2024, 19:03
ECRP Forum Name: akcoffeeman
Discord:

SAJB Awards

Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

Post by Rowin Lawson »

Image



San Andreas Judicial Branch

Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

MOTION FOR DISCOVERY

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
#26-BT-0042

A Motion for Discovery was filed in the above case on the 8th day of June, 2026.


The State of San Andreas, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion for Discovery, and presents the following as evidence;

  • Exhibit #04: Joe Ryan - 11/MAR/2026
    Enter any evidence such as CCTV footage, Fingerprints, DNA, etc.
    Joe Ryan - 11/MAR/2026
  • Exhibit #05: Vehicle Lilliana Arrived in
    Enter any evidence such as CCTV footage, Fingerprints, DNA, etc.
    Image
  • Exhibit #06: BF Jow arrived in
    Enter any evidence such as CCTV footage, Fingerprints, DNA, etc.
    Image
  • Exhibit #08: BF of joe Ryan During the pursuit
    Black BF400 [W44JKI48]
    Image
  • Exhibit #09: CCTV Footage of Route 68 Store Robbery
    Enter any evidence such as CCTV footage, Fingerprints, DNA, etc.
    Image
      Image
    • Exhibit #10: CCTV Footage of Los Santos Gun Club Store Robbery
      Enter any evidence such as CCTV footage, Fingerprints, DNA, etc.
      Image
        Image
      Rowin Lawson
      Attorney General
      San Andreas Judicial Branch
      451-9939 - [email protected]
      Image
      User avatar
      Rowin Lawson
      Judicial Branch
      Posts: 803
      Joined: 14 Jan 2024, 19:03
      ECRP Forum Name: akcoffeeman
      Discord:

      SAJB Awards

      Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

      Post by Rowin Lawson »

      Image



      San Andreas Judicial Branch

      Superior Court of San Andreas
      "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

      MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE CASES

      IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

      State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
      #26-BT-0042

      A Motion To consolidate cases was filed in the above case on the 9th day of June, 2026.


      The State of San Andreas, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion To consolidate cases;

      Upon review of the evidence submitted from the GND case file, there is a large overlap in evidence between 26-BT-0042 and 26-BT-0049 Due to the overlap The prosecution wishes to consolidate both cases into one.

      Rowin Lawson
      Attorney General
      San Andreas Judicial Branch
      451-9939 - [email protected]
      Image
      User avatar
      Rowin Lawson
      Judicial Branch
      Posts: 803
      Joined: 14 Jan 2024, 19:03
      ECRP Forum Name: akcoffeeman
      Discord:

      SAJB Awards

      Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

      Post by Rowin Lawson »

      Image



      San Andreas Judicial Branch

      Superior Court of San Andreas
      "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

      MOTION FOR CHANGE OF VENUE

      IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

      State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
      #26-BT-0042

      A Motion for Change of Venue was filed in the above case on the 9th day of June, 2026.


      The State of San Andreas, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion for Change of Venue, and the reasoning for request is as follows;

      • Requested Venue: Formal Criminal Trial
        • Detailed Explanation: Due to the amount of evidence and the potential complexity of this case the Prosecution wishes to escalate this trial to a formal criminal trial. If the motion to consolidate cases is denied, we would like to cancel this motion in attempt to avoid stretching out both cases unnecessarily.


      Rowin Lawson
      Attorney General
      San Andreas Judicial Branch
      451-9939 - [email protected]
      Image
      Lilliana Howell
      Posts: 206
      Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
      ECRP Forum Name:
      Discord:

      Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

      Post by Lilliana Howell »

      Image



      San Andreas Judicial Branch

      Superior Court of San Andreas
      "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

      MOTION TO SUPPRESS


      IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

      State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
      #26-BT-0042

      A Motion to Suppress was filed in the above case on the 9th or June, 2026.


      The Defendant, by and through the undersigned attorney, filed this Motion to Suppress, and requests to following be suppressed from evidence;


      • Exhibit #: 3 through 10
        Requested Evidence to Suppress:
        Exhibits 3 throughout 10
        • Detailed Reasoning: The Court granted a motion to compel specific discovery. The prosecution's subsequent disclosure of unrelated evidence exceeds the scope of the order and circumvents the discovery deadline. Therefore, the evidence should be excluded and the prosecution should be expected to provide MCD Case 223944 in full, not provide cherry-picked evidence after the discovery window has been closed.





      Lilliana Hirano
      Self Representing
      Image
      Lilliana Howell
      Posts: 206
      Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
      ECRP Forum Name:
      Discord:

      Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

      Post by Lilliana Howell »

      Image



      San Andreas Judicial Branch

      Superior Court of San Andreas
      "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

      REBUTTAL TO MOTION FOR INVOLUNTARY DISMISSAL

      IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

      State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
      #26-BT-0042

      A Rebuttal to the Defense’s Motion to consolidate cases was filed in the above case on the 9th day of June, 2026.


      While the Defense acknowledges that there is some overlap between the two cases, it notes that the Defendant shares only one charge of Armed Robbery with Joe Ryan, while they are appealing a total of three charges.

      It remains unclear whether Mr. Ryan had any involvement in the Defendant's additional charges of Evading an Officer and the second count of Armed Robbery.

      Given that the majority of the charges at issue are unrelated to Mr. Ryan, the Defense respectfully urges the Court to deny consolidation. Consolidating these matters would unnecessarily delay the Defendant's right to a speedy trial while providing little benefit in terms of judicial efficiency.

      Furthermore, the Prosecution has effectively acknowledged that consolidating these cases would increase their complexity to the point of requiring a Formal Criminal Trial. This further supports the Defense's position that the matters should remain separate.


      Lilliana Hirano
      Self Representing
      Image
      Last edited by Lilliana Howell on 09 Jun 2026, 16:13, edited 1 time in total.
      Lilliana Howell
      Posts: 206
      Joined: 20 Dec 2023, 16:35
      ECRP Forum Name:
      Discord:

      Re: #26-BT-0042 State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano

      Post by Lilliana Howell »

      Image



      San Andreas Judicial Branch

      Superior Court of San Andreas
      "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"

      REBUTTAL TO MOTION FOR INVOLUNTARY DISMISSAL

      IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN ANDREAS

      State of San Andreas v. Lilliana Hirano
      #26-BT-0042

      A Rebuttal to the Defense’s Motion for change of venue cases was filed in the above case on the 9th day of June, 2026.


      The Defense respectfully opposes the Prosecutions Motion for Change of Venue.

      The Prosecution argues that this matter is sufficiently complex and involves a substantial amount of evidence to warrant a Formal Criminal Trial. However, the Prosecution also acknowledges that if the Motion to Consolidate is denied, it no longer believes a Formal Criminal Trial is necessary. In doing so, the Prosecution effectively concedes that this case can be adequately managed through a standard bench trial when considered on its own merits.

      Accordingly, the Defense respectfully requests that the Court deny the Motion for Change of Venue and permit this matter to proceed as a bench trial, thereby preserving the Defendant's right to a speedy resolution rather than subjecting them to the unnecessary delays associated with scheduling a Formal Criminal Trial.


      Lilliana Hirano
      Self Representing
      Image
      Post Reply

      Return to “SAJB - Active Bench Trials”

      Who is online

      Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests