San Andreas Judicial Branch
Superior Court of San Andreas
"EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW"
Honorable Hugh Allgood and all other parties,
Your Honor,
Respectfully addressing the prosecution's response, accessing Officer Andollini's personnel file is a crucial step in upholding the principles of fairness and justice within this court case.
The prosecution asserts that the personnel file is not relevant to the current criminal charges. However, the defendant's right to a fair trial encompasses the exploration of all aspects that could potentially impact the credibility and reliability of the prosecution's key, and only, witness.
It is not a matter of a "fishing expedition." Rather, it is about ensuring that the trial is conducted with a comprehensive understanding of the witness's background, which directly influences the weight placed upon his testimony. The file's content will unveil pertinent information that might otherwise remain obscured, and thus, its relevance is undeniable.
Furthermore, the prosecution contends that there is no reasonable justification for suspecting Officer Andollini's credibility. However, it is not a matter of suspicion, but rather the obligation of the defense to comprehensively scrutinize and assess the prosecution's evidence. In a case where the defendant's fate hinges solely on the officer's account, it is a responsibility to exercise due diligence in exploring all avenues that could contribute to the defendant's defense.
As for Officer Andollini's departure from the Los Santos Police Department, the prosecution suggests that providing the names of the backup officers would be a difficult request. Yet, the necessity of obtaining this information far outweighs any procedural complexities. The pursuit of justice and the defendant's right to a fair trial should not be impeded by administrative challenges.
Lastly, the reference to a previous case's outcome has no bearing upon our request. The Defense is not seeking to dismiss the case based on a lack of evidence, we are seeking more evidence.
Respectfully,
Defense Attorney
San Andreas Judicial Branch
(909) 309-8976 —
[email protected]